When it comes to the Fall 2025 TV lineup, the schedule has been particularly robust in terms of returning favorites, whether you’re sat for the One Chicago lineup on NBC, or keeping close tabs on the latest from comedies like ABC‘s Abbott Elementary and CBS‘s Ghosts, there’s something for everyone.
As these shows carry on season to season, though, are the same audiences tuning in or tuning out? While premieres are still unfolding, the ratings from 39 returning titles offer a clearer picture of how favorite shows are faring in the TV landscape. Among some of the top performers are CBS’s hits like Tracker, Matlock, FBI, and Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage, as well as ABC’s reality smash Dancing With the Stars.
Meanwhile, you might be surprised to find where NBC’s Law & Order franchise stacks up against ABC’s sophomore shows like High Potential and Shifting Gears, or Fox‘s Doc.
Scroll down for a closer look at how the premiere episodes for 39 returning favorites ranked ratings-wise, and stay tuned to find out where upcoming premieres for Happy’s Place, St. Denis Medical, and more rank once they arrive.
