If eyes are the window to the soul then the best eyeliners are the key to unlocking them. From a Parisian smoky eye to an ultra-precise, Selena Gomez-style flick, the best eyeliners can achieve a range of results, and they come in a fittingly wide range of formulas, finishes, and shades. You can trace thin lines for a subtle eye look, experiment with tightlining for undetectable dimension, or commit to a sharp wing worthy of a close-up.
Vogue’s Favorite Eyeliners
Featured in this article
Me and eyeliner go way back—a well-crafted Brigitte Bardot-esque bold wing was a defining feature of my angsty teen makeup look. Over the years, my style has since softened—requiring a more understated flick rather than bold etchings. It’s the kind of product that evolves with you: once an emblem of rebellion, now a quiet act of refinement. Throughout my journey, I have personally tested most of the popular eyeliners on the market, in their many forms.
From classic kohls to ultra-fine gels, there are plenty of eyeliners to choose from. To determine the best, I reviewed the contents of my makeup bag, consulted several Vogue staffers, and even turned to celebrity makeup artists who understand that every stroke tells a story. Herewith, find an edit of the eyeliners industry pros and our editors love the most, plus expert tips on how to choose and apply the best eyeliner for you. It’s all looking up from here.
In This Story
Best Overall: Chanel Stylo Yeux Waterproof Long-Lasting Eyeliner
- Why We Love It: Chanel’s waterproof liner is an everyday staple that earns its place in any makeup bag, whether you’re a beginner or a seasoned pro. The thin, retractable tip makes precise application effortless, and even if your hand wavers, the smudge-resistant formula ensures your eye look remains refined. Available in 16 shades and multiple finishes, this long-wear liner is as versatile as it is elegant. It comes highly recommended by makeup artist Raquel Álvarez, who previously shared the matte brown tones as her go-to for mature skin, noting they “translate into a fresher, more natural beauty look.” Best of all, it’s waterproof—so you won’t need to bat an eyelash over smearing or fading. Whether you’re dealing with hooded eyes, humid days, or an emotional evening, this liner stays exactly where you placed it.
- Key Ingredients: Dimethicone, synthetic wax, trimethylsiloxysilicate
- Shades: 17
- Waterproof: Yes
- Type: Kohl
