Romance was about the furthest thing from our minds when we watched Monster: The Ed Gein Story. Netflix’s latest true crime series from Ryan Murphy follows serial killer Ed Gein, who killed and desecrated the bodies of multiple women in the 1950s. His crimes inspired iconic horror movies like Psycho and The Texas Chain Saw Massacre.

But now that we’ve binged all the episodes, we admittedly found ourselves wondering about the love lives of the incredible ensemble cast, which includes the likes of Charlie Hunnam (who transformed himself for the leading role), Laurie Metcalf, Suzanna Son, Addison Rae, and more.