Maybe you were one of the countless suckers who fell for the Erewhon orange juice hoax: how, according to a swirl of Instagram posts and TikTok videos, the aspirational grocery store was supposedly selling a $49 glass of citrus made from imported Japanese fruit.

Ridiculous on the face of it, preposterous even — yet somehow also kind of plausible.

Anyone who has ventured into the luxe health food emporium — where sea moss goes to find a publicist — is all too aware of its nosebleed price points. This is, after all, where bone broth is bottled like Chanel No. 5 and avocados are presented like Fabergé eggs. So, is a $49 glass of OJ really that much of a stretch? Aren’t there plenty of other actual Erewhon products that are just as outrageously expensive?

To test that proposition, here’s a little quiz. Pick which of the following Erewhon offerings are legit and which are phony. First prize is a $49 adaptogenic latte infused with reishi and ashwagandha.

Can you spot which of these Erewhon items are real and which are fake? 

***

See the answers below.

Answers: 1-7 are real, shown with actual prices at press time.

This story appeared in the Sept. 18 issue of The Hollywood Reporter magazine. Click here to subscribe.