[Warning: The below contains MAJOR spoilers for Providence Falls: Thief of Fate.]

Cora (Katie Stevens) and Liam’s (Lachlan Quarmby) time-traveling love story has captured the hearts of Hallmark fans everywhere. Over the course of three parts, we watched Cora and Liam fight for each other in every lifetime. From 1844 Ireland to modern-day Providence Falls, nothing could keep these two apart.

Despite angels urging Liam to help Cora fall in love with another man so she can achieve her destiny, Cora refuses to let Liam go once she regains all of her memories from their past life together. “I choose Liam. In every life, every time,” Cora says. The angels allow Cora and Liam to be together. A year later, Cora still fulfills her destiny with Liam by her side. Katie Stevens and Lachlan Quarmby spoke with Swooon about the ending of Providence Falls and whether or not there’s more of Cora and Liam’s story to tell.