Leslie Fhima and Gary Levingston formed a strong connection on Season 10 of Bachelor in Paradise. However, a twist in Week 5 led to their elimination after they found themselves in the bottom three following a compatibility challenge.

At that point, it was up to the female in the winning couple, Bailey Brown, to decide which two of the bottom three ladies would get roses to hand out at the next rose ceremony. She ultimately went with Parisa Shifteh and Faith Martin, who gave their roses to Brian Autz and Kim Buike, respectively. That left Gary and Leslie remaining, which meant they were sent home.