[Warning: The following post contains MAJOR spoilers for Too Much Season 1.]

Too Much has arrived on Netflix, and it’s full of swoony moments for the couple at the heart of this rom-com series. Jessica (Megan Stalter) is an American transplant making her way in London, and Felix (Will Sharpe) is the musician and performer who happens to steal her heart.

While they’re not without their ups and downs throughout the 10-episode season, we caught up with Stalter, Sharpe, and series creator Lena Dunham to find out their favorite romantic moments from the show. It soon became quite clear that this trio is on the same page, as they all cited Episode 2’s mixtape listening session in which Felix makes Jessica a mixtape and the pair quietly listens to it on her bed.