The contents of our bathroom cabinets can be very revealing. Who can forget a pre-Glossier Emily Weiss documenting the beauty top shelves of industry luminaries for Into the Gloss? Or, indeed, the fascination with which we watch every new video in Architectural Digest’s Open Door series, zooming in on the bathroom sinks and capacious rainfall showers in celebrity homes, trying to spot the products they turn to every single day?

So, naturally, when the latest episode of And Just Like That’s (let’s just say it, quite bonkers) third season offered us not one but two (!) glimpses of our beloved Carrie Bradshaw’s top shelf, I, of course, took notice. Our favorite New Yorker’s madcap outfits have always been meticulously dissected, so it was now time to apply the same care and attention to her beauty essentials.

And they are… well, quite surprising. French pharmacy staples? Bien sûr. But also a number of products from Neutrogena? It’s not quite what I expected from the woman who wears Simone Rocha just to swan around her cavernous Gramercy Park townhouse. Nor is the Dove hand wash in lieu of, say, Aesop, though I am, personally, choosing to ignore the Speed Stick deodorant, which I can only assume is Aidan’s. (He is shown to have the same one at home in Virginia.)

Elsewhere, the items are indicative of the crossroads this gal about town-turned-gal who’s put her life on hold for her man finds herself at: there’s a body shimmer, ideal for slathering across your décolletage before strutting to a dive bar to hang out with Katerina Tannenbaum’s Lisette, but also a coral-colored nail polish which is literally called “Peachy Keen” and goes perfectly with Carrie’s recent rotation of floaty, Trad Wife frocks.

Now, without further ado, we present the contents of Carrie Bradshaw’s bathroom cabinet, below.

Have a beauty or wellness trend you’re curious about? We want to know! Send Vogue’s senior beauty & wellness editor an email at beauty@vogue.com.