Reality TV fans first fell in love with Hugo Wentzel and Olivia Aquilina during Season 2 of ABC’s Claim to Fame. Two years after their stint on the celebrity relatives competition show, Wentzel, who is President Jimmy Carter and First Lady Rosalynn Carter‘s grandson, and Olivia, who is Jenny McCarthy‘s niece, are still going strong today.

The couple recently sat down with Swooon for our Summer Catch-Up series to discuss the early days of their relationship, their exciting plans for the summer, Wentzel’s love for the Chili’s Triple Dipper, and more. Scroll down for our chat with Hugo Wentzel and Olivia Aquilina, and make sure to check back soon to find out which other reality TV shows are on their relationship bucket list!