Andy Taylor might have been Mayberry’s sheriff, but he was also one of television’s most eligible bachelors. Played with an easy charm by Andy Griffith, Andy didn’t fall in love easily or often, but when he did, the women were warm and intelligent. Across The Andy Griffith Show‘s eight seasons, three major love interests stood out, each leaving her own mark on the show. But who was Andy’s best match? Read on to learn a bit more about each of them, and vote in our poll: