Viewers of The Hills spent three and a half seasons waiting to see if Lauren Conrad and Brody Jenner would ever actually get together. Jenner joined the show in Season 2 and remained a cast member until Conrad’s departure in the middle of Season 5.

But while the two shared a few kisses and went on some dates, their relationship never progressed into anything more. With May 31 being the 19th anniversary of The Hills’ premiere in 2006, we’re looking back at the truth behind Jenner and Conrad’s romance.