It’s been nearly three years since T.J. Holmes and Amy Robach‘s relationship went public, but have they taken the next step and secretly walked down the aisle? Holmes had fans asking that question after a comment he made on an episode of the I Do, Part 2, podcast.

The couple was having a conversation with longtime lovers Gretchen Rossi and Slade Smiley. They ended the chat with Rossi saying, “We wish you guys luck in your relationship, too. I know you guys have been through a lot.” Holmes replied, “My wife and I appreciate that.”