The scandalous story dominated Hollywood, but a suspect could never be nailed down. As the New York Times put it 70 years later, “Was the murderer a seduced virgin, her jealous mother, the gay butler, the drug-addicted actress, the blackmailing secretary, or someone from William Desmond Taylor’s mysterious past?” 

A little over 100 years after the murder, it seems that Taylor’s case will forever remain cold — but that doesn’t mean that modern imagination isn’t still infatuated by it. In fact, just a few years ago the case was the subject of a popular BuzzFeed Unsolved video!