[Warning: The below contains MAJOR spoilers for Haul Out the Halloween.]

Look, Everscream Lane has a nice ring to it. The Haul Out the Holly universe expanded with Haul Out the Halloween. Emily (Lacey Chabert), Jared (Wes Brown), and the entire cul-de-sac came together to welcome Marvin (Daniel Kountz) and Luna (Kimberly J. Brown) to the neighborhood. The beloved characters in the newest Hallmark movie took their Halloween celebrations to a new level.

Naturally, given how Haul Out the Halloween ends, we couldn’t help but wonder if a Haul Out the Halloween sequel is on the horizon, or if it’s possible another type of Evergreen Lane celebration will join the universe. Swooon asked Brown and Melissa Peterman to weigh in.