[Warning: The below contains MAJOR spoilers for All of You.]

Don’t let All of You‘s Simon (Brett Goldstein) and Laura’s (Imogen Poots) jokes fool you: the movie has a sad ending. Or does it?

The Apple TV+ romantic drama puts the duo in an impossible conundrum, as Poots puts it. Set in a not-so-distant future, the best friends — who harbor unspoken feelings for each other — live in a world where a test can determine who their soulmate is. Simon is against the idea entirely, but Laura decides it’s time to find (and marry) her match. Over the next 12 years, we only see the brief moments that Simon and Laura reunite, the former coming back into Laura’s life whenever she needs him.