There’s no doubt about it: Bridgerton knows how to do a first kiss. But is one smooch better than the others?

It’s a question we found ourselves asking as we anxiously wait for the romance show’s fourth season. It’ll be months until we’re able to compare Benedict (Luke Thompson) and Sophie’s (Yerin Ha) kiss to the others, but in the meantime, let’s evaluate their competition. First, they’re up against Daphne (Phoebe Dynevor) and Simon (Regé-Jean Page) from Season 1. It’s been a few years — for those that haven’t rewatched it — so let’s take a trip down memory lane.