We’re still in our Providence Falls era, to be honest. Hallmark’s three-part television event was the perfect mix of romance, fantasy, and a period drama.

Who didn’t love watching Cora (Katie Stevens) and Liam’s (Lachlan Quarmby) love prevail in every lifetime? Whether it was 1844 Ireland or modern-day Providence Falls, these two lovers were destined to be together no matter what. When you defy the angels and still get a happily ever after (following some intense yearning), you know you have an epic romance on your hands.