The inaugural season of 90 Day: Hunt for Love may have come to an end, but we’re still reeling over the explosive summer singles show.

90 Day: Hunt for Love followed eight fan-favorite 90 Day Fiancé franchise alums to an exclusive singles-only resort in Tulum, with the hope of finding love with each other and franchise newbies. Characterized by a whirlwind of masquerade balls, hot-tub speed-dating, and unexpected love triangles, Season 1 proved to be an unforgettable viewing experience.