Gilmore Girls fans, you’ve probably seen the entire series multiple times (I sure have), but did you know there was an original pilot that never saw the light of day? Luckily for us, the unaired pilot found its way on the internet somehow, and even if you’ve seen the series multiple times, you’ll be shocked — because there are some unfamiliar faces in it.

The original pilot follows the same storyline as the pilot that we know and love, but two of the characters are played by completely different actors; there are other small changes, as well.